Sunday, June 3, 2007

Strategy Section--Trace the Insider Buying Stocks(1)

1) Introduction

Before start to discuss about this, I would like to clarify that even I just explore this strategy which first knew from the book " Finding the next starbucks " and further proposed by bobobobo. The inputs from all of you are necessary and appreciated so that we can build a reasonable sound model for consistent performance. Can we do that? I think we can.

Trade based on insider buying has been existing for quite a while and has been used by peter lynch quite a lot ( described in his book << One up on the street >> ). The method won't be obsolete even it has been used widely for its fundamental reasons which can be summarized as below:

1)Insider behavior matters because research based on real-time signals has shown that a properly modeled picture of insider actions can provide the most accurate reflection of the prospects for the company, industry, economic sector, or even the stock market in general, going forward.

2) This makes perfect sense from an intuitive perspective. Corporate insiders possess all the necessary skills and characteristics that one could use to describe the "successful" investor. These include: A deep knowledge and understanding of the company and/or industry; A demonstrated ability to produce success; The training necessary to understand risk and to control it; The wherewithal (capital) to take advantage of opportunity when it presents itself and finally; A tendency to go against the crowd.

3) Further, insider buys are especially useful. Since insiders have exclusive information on the company performance, if they are risking their own money on the stock, usually they should have good reasons, especially when several insiders buy the stock at the same time.

Pls pay attention here, we only care about insider buying not selling with an assumption of a long position in the stock not a short one. The insider selling have different explanation sometimes that we will further elaborate in the future. But as an initiative, we wanna focus on a long position first, not to be distracted.

In order to fully explore the benefits of such strategy, we propose to investigate from several perspectives highly related to potential gain in a middle term, i.e. 6 months, with an expected return on investment about 30%. You may argue it could be a little bit high, but through our further research, the portfolio build from such strategy could yield at least more than the general market yield. The perspectives will be divided into 3 sections which are 1) Building the universe of active insider buying stocks, a methodology to find those companies that have intensive insider buying in the past 3 months or 6 months for different time frame. 2) Reducing the trading candidate, a process that we use fundamental research to filter out those candidates that having high probability to succeed. 3) Entry and Exist Analysis, a strategy that describes how we are going to trade into those stocks after step two. Step 3 is quite important for implementation. We could find if we invest at a wrong time, loss could be huge even the company is pretty good. For example, if we pay $1000 for GOOG now, would it be a good one?

Those three steps are complementary to each other which can't be separated to ensure that our goal can be achieved. Each step in the strategy needs to be investigate the potential pros and cons so that drawbacks in each step could be minimized.

NOTE: if you have any ideas and thinking in each step, pls email me at totalmerrill@hotmail.com or leave your msg here. Any ideas would receive fully attention during such strategy building process. You know a strategy can't be improved without different sources.

by the way, all of the articles related to this strategy would be published at Investshuttle.com, the site that I built to upload our pdf files. The introduction page can be downloaded now.

96 comments:

Carol said...

Let's "Just do it"!

brisk said...

great! cannot wait for further exploration of this method.

Carol said...

千户,对于第一点,我觉得可以对几个sector找出代表股,然后找人分别追踪这几只股票的insider buying.比如我可以帮你负责一个sector的。到时候大家看到自己负责的sector里边那些股票有动作,就回报到你这里。这样不用一个人看,看不过来。每个人负责好自己的一亩三分地就行了,也顺便学习了这个sector的整体情况,也可以帮助大家把握这个sector的走向。不知道俺的想法可行不?

Metronic said...

Hi Brisk,
you are also experienced investors, any idea? hehe

Metronic said...

to Carol,
that is an excellent idea, i really like that one. We can share the burden and contribute together!:)

brisk said...

I sent you an email about some posts. (dont want to make it like ad, so didnt post the links here. :P)
I have a program that can grab insider transaction and also can overlay the event on price chart.

Here are some sites:
j3sg.com
secform4.com

Some friends and I started this insider play last year and later no time on it to continue. Hope this time we can get some good result out of this.

Carol said...

nod, qianhu. I will be so happy to contribute. Giving is always more pleasant than taking :-)
Brisk, you are also bigbull and you already have your system to track AH performance. I am sure you can lead our way with qianhu to this "project". I am waiting for my assignment from qianhu now, haha, so exciting!

brisk said...

carol, I like your idea. sector play is my all time favorite, but it is too much for one single person( at least for me now). In old golden time of goofiz, we did this and I think it was really good. Now it is gone and I am doing it all by myself. I got these sectors by far, (http://www.fortuneseeds.com/sectorplay.php) and no time to focus on all of them. If we can do some collaborative work on it, that will be great.

bobby said...

Qianhu, about point 1. In addition to the insider buying (defined by buying shares and/or option awarded?), for which the buyers are required to file within 2 days, shall we also include signals from new buys by high-grade growth funds, which are available weeks after the end of the funds' quarter?

Unknown said...

老大,怎么看leading sector阿?

brisk said...

qianhu, carol,
I am not experienced nor bigbull in any way. I only did some coding since I am lazy, hehe. qianhu's sector sense is great, I benefit a lot from him. I am very happy to help, following qianhu's direction. :P

bobby said...

怎么看leading sector?
IBD 197 industry group ranking and change of ranking?

brisk said...

bobby,
"new buys by high-grade growth funds," is this institutional buying? Where can we get this information realtime or without much delay?
thomson used have this information, but now not accessible.

Carol said...

Brisk, thanks for your encouragement. I'd glad to help in anyway I can. Maybe we can even give you inspiration to perfect your system! We should have video conference call, haha.....We can even give tasks according everybody's relative strength. For example, qianhu may know more about Electronics/tech and I might be more familiar with power/utility. We should definitely go for it, worth to try!

Carol said...

bobby, I think we can use as much info as we can in the beginning and then narrow down to the most effective ones later on as we improve our skill set. So if we could get that info, would be more than welcome!

bobby said...

yes, it is just institutional buying, but focusing on the good performing growth funds. I don't know how to get such information sooner than reading the quarter prospectus of the fund. However, even if we get such information late, the buying cost should provide a sound support level for the stock.

brisk said...

sterm, there are quite some websites have sector performance information, like seekingalpha, and I googled and found more today. here is one
http://www.themoneyblogs.com/millionairenow/my.blog/10-best-and-10-worst-performing-industries-week-ending-62.html

brisk said...

long url cut off.
http://www.themoneyblogs.com/millionairenow/
my.blog/10-best-and-10-worst-
performing-industries-week-ending-62.html

Carol said...

Wow, a lot of good info! 乱花渐欲迷人眼,浅草才能没马蹄. 18 posts within an hour, qianhu, u should be proud of your blog!

Metronic said...

to brisk,

==
Here are some sites:
j3sg.com
secform4.com

Some friends and I started this insider play last year and later no time on it to continue. Hope this time we can get some good result out of this.
===
That is good. I will follow that.
secform4.com is a good place which will definately a point to be included in step 1.:) thanks.

Metronic said...

To bobby,
=========
1. In addition to the insider buying (defined by buying shares and/or option awarded?), for which the buyers are required to file within 2 days, shall we also include signals from new buys by high-grade growth funds, which are available weeks after the end of the funds' quarter?
=========
We may not study those purchase by mutual fund becasue they are not regarded as insiders. Furthermore, MF designed with an intention to keep it growth or saving purpose which will conflict with our 30% gain or at least beat the market gain purpose :) But I think mutual fund buying are sometime important.

Metronic said...

to fanzhi,
what bobby said is correct, IBD top sector info are very important reference in my report.

===
bobby,
怎么看leading sector?
IBD 197 industry group ranking and change of ranking?
=======
to bobby,
their ranking has a delay a little bit. So what I normally do is to take the top20 sector out and then monitor myself by using an indicator similar as RSI to determine their strength.
:)

Metronic said...

To carol,
hehe, how do we setup a conference call ? can netmeeting work?

we may need to do that. hehe

Metronic said...

Leading sector,

there is also a link on my blog,
which can help to track:)

Metronic said...

to Bobby,

===
yes, it is just institutional buying, but focusing on the good performing growth funds. I don't know how to get such information sooner than reading the quarter prospectus of the fund. However, even if we get such information late, the buying cost should provide a sound support level for the stock.
===========
Yes, institution buying is quite important I agree.:) If large institution buying ,will mean they are bullish on those stocks. We can follow too. That could be another strategy.

brisk said...

To qianhu
"using an indicator similar as RSI to determine their strength"
could you share a bit more about this, or point a direction? I am struggling on this topic now. thx!

Metronic said...

hi Brisk,
yes, first, take out top 20 sector from IBD group ranking. Then find the corresponding index related to each sector ( if you can't find the index, then get the corresponding ETF), put them into a excel list or simply just add those etf into yahoo realtime chart. Calculate the indicator as the same as RSI index calculation.
RSI = 100 - 100
______
1 + RS

RS = Average of x days' up closes / Average of x days' down closes

this is pretty much what I do.Hope you can come up better way because i don't know how to program to catch those data online.

brisk said...

thx qianhu! It helps a lot.
I am also thinking, since one sector has so many stocks, and we only focus on leading stocks, if we come up with something like our own sector index based on these leading stocks only, then it may be more useful, or maybe it will be misleading. I dont know.

Metronic said...

hi brisk,
hehe actually leading sector index is misleading somehow in term of sector strength just according to my experience.
but for individual stock analysis, that is quite useful. :)

Carol said...

Qianhu, I will ask about it, I know somebody did it over memory board :-)
At least, we could use msn to do it!
I can also help setup our own bbs site (similar to 168) about this since my LD is an IT guy for EE department here:-) Just let me know what your thoughts are and I am definitely in!

Metronic said...

To carol,
hehe setup a bbs is simple , the difficult thing is who is going to do the maintenance work.
maybe get a way to setup CC will be better so far I think:)

Carol said...

CC is easier than bbs I think, hehe. I was just thinking that posting on blogs is easy to get lost due to the increasing popularity of it (like urs). BBS has the advantage of boards and threads. For example, each sector can be a board with a designated moderator, my LD can help with maintenance on a pure technical base.
I will let u know about cc, if u r on msn, send me a msg and we can try it out.

Metronic said...

hi Carol,
you mean using the MSN's call function? can he include many people instead of two?

Carol said...

haha, of course. why r u hiding on msn? let's try it out, hiahia

Carol said...

ft...........明晚再说吧,呵呵。总是错过一点点,555

Metronic said...

Carol,
sorry, I am not hiding, just need to get some stocks from A market hehe and didn't look at here.

happydayone said...

wa, this is a very good idea. I like carol' suggestion to monitor the sector leader's insider transaction. I can do one or two sectors if you don't mind. I am waiting for the assignment

bobobobo said...

qianhu,

do you still remember we talked about palm could be a buy out target when you first started your blog. look at its headline news today. tmmd, I miss it.

skiii,

你牛啊, 7天才在stockboard 上发了7个帖。搞了grow and ICFI,比那些个灌水wsn强多了。这样发展下去,一年后我就帮你拎包得了。

反指

赌博开始了。

今天我会越跌越买。这就是我上周5清仓hold 70% cash的原因

dangqiwu said...

bobo大哥,

I learn all the methods from you~ You're my mentor! I know GROW from you. But not sure if ICFI will break, seems the next resistence is at 19.5, $1 from now.
About the market, 大哥别吓我, my GOOG option just get out of water, my QQQQ option in deep water, but thank to GROW and ONXX, my account keeps a little green.
It seems the market will close at green today. I'll keep my left GOOG and QQQQ and just wait. No matter how deep the MMs will test.
If I'm wrong, please guide me. Thanks~

Carol said...

bobo, you are right about today's market :-) Thanks!

Metronic said...

to bobobobo,
hoho, the palm can really be sold? amazing. I thought its tech is obsolete. But we probably will need to restate our strategy discussion after finishing this one. I know you also study a lot in the insider buyout strategy .

dangqiwu said...

bobo大哥,
You asked me which area I am. I'm in central US~ One hour ahead of stock market ^_^

bobobobo said...

qianhu brother

how's the CFA exam?

I was busy watching the french open over the weekend.

regarding palm, dell/msft all could be potential buyers.

SleepyCat said...

千户 and carol, 我是新手,想看看能不能在alternative engergy sector 还有programming 方面 contribute 一下。

bobobobo said...

to skiii,

"About the market, 大哥别吓我"
-------------------------you probably read too much english and start to mis understand chinese. :))

don't tell me you live in ne.

Metronic said...

hey bobobobo dude,
My CFA exam I can finish ahead of time, but not sure about the ethics part which can or can not alter the final results. We will have to see. :)

overall, are you trading on GROW?

Metronic said...

to sleepycat,
yes, welcome so much:)

Carol said...

Bobo, one question for you. When do you think would be a good time for a newbie like me to start option trading? Thanks!

Metronic said...

hehe,
I think the big market needs time to correct, we should focus more on tech sector especially on tech growth stocks. For example, the palm, rack, sndk brcm, sirf.
They will tend to outperform .

Metronic said...

carol,
I think your hand is so quick that can catch back AOB so fast. hehe
awesome.

bobobobo said...

to Carol

whenever you can only have 7 posts in 7 days like skiii, you are ready to go.

dangqiwu said...

bobo大哥,
I feel safe with your confirmation about the direction of the market.
I sold all GOOG options with little profit and keep QQQQ.
I'm in OK~ Are you in NE? Not far, haha.

Qianhu,
I'd like to make contribute to your strategy, just like carol and happydayone, hehe.
BTW, Do you have any new pick recently? :)

dangqiwu said...

bobo大哥
----------------------------------
to Carol

whenever you can only have 7 posts in 7 days like skiii, you are ready to go.
----------------------------------
Don't say that. I'm still a newbie.

Carol,
What's your ID on mitbbs? Mine is skiii.

bobobobo said...

qianhu,

I didn't get in to grow last friday. part of the reason was I spent time on last thursday night, helping my Kenya friend making copies of his old projects, so that I didn't have time to go over my watch list. and the market didn't up that much as I was expected on friday.

the reason for why I ask the cfa exam is that I am also thinking about change my career at this point.

but anyway, let me make fanzhi lost his underware first. the bet is if nmx can close above 128 before the market close on Tue, I can win 200 mit weibi. he only has 205 at this point, and among that 205, 120 was borrowed from me with 1% daily interest.

let's see how things will go.

Carol said...

Qianhu, I only know sirf of your list, I will watch it. AOB is fine, I will just load n watch, thanks!
Bobo, thanks. I am not watering now, please keep an eye on me and scold me if I do :-(
Skiii, I'll send u pm.

SleepyCat said...

Qianhu, I feel alternative engergy will keep going strong after discussion with xt.

Take a look of EMU and DNN, (for DNN's history, we should look at DML -DNN's Candada symbol): http://finance.yahoo.com/charts#chart1:symbol=dml.to;range=5y;indicator=sma+volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;logscale=on;source=undefined)

Metronic said...

to skiii,
thanks for your offer:) I will definately need your hands.
as for new pick, I do have several stocks are under studied, but I need time to finish them:)

Metronic said...

hey bobobobo dude,
===
the reason for why I ask the cfa exam is that I am also thinking about change my career at this point.
====
are you really serious about that? because I haven't worked therefore just need to prepare for any case. But CFA test is not that hard I think as long as time and effort spent. I still think 2 weeks are too short for me and i really underestimate this test. hehe

happydayone said...

NVEC, watch it out.

Metronic said...

hi sleepycat,
XT is really good at exploring alternative energy sector. In summer we will see another bull rally. But short term correction is welcomed too.

The DNN will have a high chance to break 16 in my chart.

good pick:)

Metronic said...

hehe happydayone,
you get in?

happydayone said...

I got in last week

happydayone said...

qianhu: If poosible, please help me look at BGC's balance sheet and cash flow. Thank.

m31 said...

Sorry for the repeating update, I just want to remind Carol and Qianhu AOB's news on selling new shares. What happens when the company offer more public shares? Is the new stock price proportionally adjusted since the company's capital is not changed? That mean's the price can go down to $8.7 or so. Did I misunderstand this?

sunshine said...

Sounds an interesting topic here. I used secform4 to check every stock before I buy it. But didn't think to use it as a strategy
I would like to participate and contribute.
Right now I am looking at metal minging sector, such as Palladium,Lithium

Metronic said...

to happydayone,
BGC has a very nice balance sheet together with its income statement. They have a free cash flow to support their recent growth. They have an improved management and production process compared to its past three years according to the cash turnover day's improvement. More to focus is that they have an aggressive financing plan to collect enough cash. I would really suspect they will try to buy out the other companies. I would rec to study those potential buyout targets of this company which could yield surprise profit.

Metronic said...

to m31,
your concern is reasonable, normally after an issue of a new share, the stock price will drop, so does its earning per share. However we can't predict the future soly based on this. We need to think about the financing strategy by such an offering. And they do have enough cash in hand, the additional 13m share offering also mean they have a big plan in their queue. this is my experience.

Metronic said...

to sunshine,
thanks for offering:)

Carol said...

Qianhu, 辛苦了,呵呵。I will hold AOB :-)

happydayone said...

many thanks, Qianhu. BTW, my grow was stolen by MM this morning. NND!!!

Metronic said...

the only thing I feel happy today is that I had aapl in my account now. But I feel bad that I am short of money today when I see ICE rock in front of me.

bobby said...

The market showed great strength at the last trading hour. Sigh, I cannot wait for the 3% correction predicted by qianhu anymore. I am fully loaded. In AMZN, in FMCN.

happydayone said...

can anybody help me how to trade in IB AH?

Metronic said...

hehe bobby,
My prediction could be wrong this time. But I still think market is doomed for a correction in this week. Actually today's movment showed institution's expectation too. they shift their position into sector leaders generally for example ISRG,ICE, SNDK,AMZN,AAPL,GOOG,BOT,NYX those traditional group leader to reduce their risk. While what I saw from IBD top100 is that more than 60 stocks are in red, general under ground market is not as comparable as they did. Generally, when we see those sector leaders shown 3% increase perday, NAZ should add at least 40 points, DOWS should add at least 100 points. But market becomes red most of the time until the last hour closed with 8 points,and 4 points.

This will need us attention. Focus on individual stocks especial those stocks who haven't grow up too much deserve a try:)

But don't blame me if I were wrong this time:)

brisk said...

happydayone, there is a setting in IB configuration to allow AH trading. by default it is not enabled.

Carol said...

bobby, bso ah, hehe. Congrats for AMZN today. I took a risk today, will see how it goes the next two days.
Qianhu,keep me updated on ur thoughts about cc.

Metronic said...

to happydayone,
are you using st or ib, in st you can choose AH/BH in trading session selection.

happydayone said...

selected all the time-in-force option for order? I did it, still didn't work. Please let me know which item I should go to change?

happydayone said...

IB

Metronic said...

yes, I really envy all of you here having more fund than I do in US market now. hehe

Bobby made a good move today, but I would rec to close those position quickly.

Carol said...

ah! close quickly.....how about my new position today? Under water :(

happydayone said...

"yes, I really envy all of you here having more fund than I do in US market now. hehe."

Me too. I need margin all the time. I am out of NVEC since I am really out of patience. One week hols just give me 0.60 gain. What a pain when seeing other picks flys to the heaven

happydayone said...

what is your position, Carol? hmin

Metronic said...

carol,
you are making money in grow right?
:)

Carol said...

I wanted to load HMIN, but forgot to watch. Sigh~~

Carol said...

Qianhu, my first ride did, my second ride under water now :-(

Metronic said...

to happydayone,
I would think NVEC is not a good buy as I pointed out before at its current appreciation.

and you may feel better if I told you that only 3% out of IBD TOP 100 increases 2% today and over 60 of them are in red. Those traditional group sector leaders' performance today is suspicious. We will have a clear shot by tomorrow. I also need to find out what is behind the move today. Now my first intuitive is that they shift their risk.

bobby said...

hehe, carol, I did not even say that I got in ICE early morning (dumped too early though).

Yes, I am very alert because I also think the broader market is not strong. Utility, transportation down. hehe, I always learn tricks from Qianhu.

brisk said...

happydayone, in IB tws, configuration->Order->STK: Allow order filled only in regular hour. Uncheck it.

Metronic said...

sorry, a typo,
==========
not and you may feel better if I told you that only 3% out of IBD TOP 100
===
not 3% but 3(but they are equal hehe).

only 4 stocks out of IBD top 100 increase more than 2% with increasing volume today.

Metronic said...

to Bobby,
yes, hehe Utility, transportation, two strongest sector weaken, transportation sector is in red today most of the time. Bobby, you should hold longer on ICE hehe.

Carol said...

bobby, selling early is always better than selling late ah. I have to set a stop tonight, 555.
brisk, looking forward to ur AH data. :-)

Carol said...

qianhu, now it take 5 minutes to drag down the scrolling bar on ur blog!

Metronic said...

carol,
maybe I should open a new thread and talk about your idea of CC. Today brisk offers the space for building a forum during our strategy building process. That is so kind I think. :)

happydayone said...

thanks, brisk I will try it when I get home.

Carol said...

That's cool, we should surely discuss it. BTW, u know you can send a msg even if you are offline on msn, right?